Maple Leafs head coach Jim Hiller will not play Gavin McKenna in overtime because he does not believe the first overall pick is ready.

Thursday night, Toronto dropped a 4-3 shootout decision to the Kings, and the 18-year-old forward once again watched extra time from the bench. That choice came right after Jim Hiller benched Gavin McKenna late against the Kings during the third period.

Hiller simply does not believe his top pick is ready for the demands of sudden death hockey.

McKenna has not played a single second of overtime through 24 games this season. For an 18-year-old with elite offensive instincts, sitting through high-stakes moments while Toronto chases points sends a clear message about defensive trust.

Against Los Angeles on Thursday, McKenna finished with 14:28 of ice time and two shots on goal. He was held scoreless, leaving him with two points over his last five games and six goals on the season.

Toronto did get offense from Auston Matthews, who had a goal and an assist, and John Tavares, who also scored. Anthony Stolarz stopped 25 of 28 shots, but the Maple Leafs still could not find the winner in the shootout.

McKenna has 14 points and a -9 rating through his first 24 career games. The offensive output shows up in flashes, including three power-play goals, but Hiller has kept a tight leash on his 5-on-5 and late-game deployment.

GAVIN MCKENNA
BY THE NUMBERS (BEFORE TONIGHT'S GAME)
GPGAPTS+/-
2026-27246814-9
Last 1010336-3
Last 55022+1
Career246814-9


Over his last 10 games, the young winger has three goals and three assists. Those numbers show steady involvement, yet Toronto continues to lean almost exclusively on its veteran core when games hang in the balance.

Can Toronto afford to keep Gavin McKenna off the ice in extra time?

Three-on-three overtime is built for space, quick transitions, and elite finishing skill. Keeping a player of McKenna's caliber on the pine during open-ice hockey feels like coaching out of fear rather than attacking to win.

Toronto came into Thursday having lost eight straight games, and playing safe has clearly not solved the slump. When a team is struggling to generate extra points, leaving dynamic skill on the bench in wide-open ice makes little hockey sense.

Matthews logged over 25 minutes against the Kings, and Darren Raddysh also topped 25 minutes. Relying so heavily on a handful of skaters while an offensive weapon sits cold creates an unnecessary physical toll over a long homestand.

With Columbus visiting on Saturday, Hiller will face this exact decision the next time a game pushes past 60 minutes. At some point, Toronto needs to give McKenna the green light and see what he can do with all that ice.

This article was written with the help of artificial intelligence, based on public reports and official sources.

POLL
1 HOUR AGO |12 ANSWERS
Jim Hiller holds Gavin McKenna out of Maple Leafs overtime for a blunt reason

Should Jim Hiller use Gavin McKenna in overtime?

Also read on Markerzone.com:
Gavin McKenna's latest play could put him under Jim Hiller's microscope