Jim Hiller raised eyebrows tonight by keeping Gavin McKenna entirely off the ice in overtime and the shootout against Los Angeles.
The Maple Leafs dropped a 4-3 shootout decision to the Kings, extending a miserable slide for a franchise searching for traction. Toronto has been watching Gavin McKenna's latest play under Jim Hiller's microscope, and that tension spilled directly into game action.
McKenna skated 14:28 in regulation, but did not receive a single second of ice time in overtime or an attempt in the shootout.
-
Leaving the 2026 first overall pick on the bench during three-on-three play is a baffling choice. Open ice is built for players with elite skating and high-end vision, two traits that define the 18-year-old forward.
If there is any environment where a young creator can break a game open, it is the extra frame. Instead, Toronto played conservatively and failed to capitalize before the game slipped away.
Why benching Gavin McKenna in extra time makes little sense
The Maple Leafs entered the night sitting 27th in the NHL with an 8-13-2 record, having lost seven straight contests before this defeat. When a team cannot buy a win, refusing to unleash offensive skill feels like coaching out of fear.
The shootout decision was even harder to justify. McKenna has six goals and 14 points through 23 games this season, showing flashes of game-breaking talent that belong in a one-on-one showdown against an opposing goaltender.
The rookie forward picked up two assists over his last five appearances, navigating tight checking while trying to establish his footing.
Hiller has shown a willingness to send loud messages, even shaking up his lines by demoting William Nylander to the third line earlier in the day. Teaching defense to an 18-year-old matters, but benching him in the shootout does nothing to teach defensive structure.
Toronto now turns its attention to a home matchup against Columbus on Saturday. If the coaching staff continues to hold back its best young offensive weapon, the frustration around this group will only escalate.
This article was written with the help of artificial intelligence, based on public reports and official sources.
Should Jim Hiller have used Gavin McKenna in overtime and the shootout?
Also read on Markerzone.com:
Gavin McKenna's latest play could put him under Jim Hiller's microscope