SEARCH


Pierre LeBrun just changed the conversation around Auston Matthews' future in Toronto

PUBLICATION
Vincent Carbonneau
May 31, 2026  (5:10 PM)
SHARE THIS STORY

Mar 5, 2026; New York, New York, USA; Toronto Maple Leafs center Auston Matthews (34) skates against the New York Rangers during the third period at Madison Square Garden.
Photo credit: Brad Penner-Imagn Images

Auston Matthews and John Chayka are now tied to a trade angle that could actually strengthen Toronto's position, not weaken it.

That is the twist in Pierre LeBrun's latest report.

If Matthews ever opens the door to a move, Anaheim could be one of the destinations on his list, with the Ducks holding enough young pieces to make a real offer. Mason McTavish is the name already being floated as part of that kind of package.

That is a huge development.

Not because the Leafs are suddenly shopping their captain.

Because every credible destination that surfaces changes the math for Toronto.

Before the draft lottery, a Matthews trade would have felt like panic. The Leafs had missed the playoffs, the noise around the core was building, and any move involving their biggest star would have looked like a franchise losing control.

Then everything changed.

Winning the first overall pick gave Toronto a new lever, and the file points directly to Gavin McKenna as the type of entry-level cornerstone who changes how patient Chayka can afford to be.

" If Auston Matthews...decides he's not sure they are still a contender and says he's open to a move, I would venture to guess Anaheim would be on his list of seven or eight potential desired landing spots; the Ducks would have the pieces."

- Pierre LeBrun

A shocking Auston Matthews development was just revealed by Pierre LeBrun

That is the part Leafs fans need to understand.

If Matthews ever decides he is not fully sold on the team's direction and becomes open to moving, Toronto would not be negotiating from fear. It would be negotiating from strength.

That is a major difference.

The file even frames it this way: the longer the destination list gets, the more it starts to resemble a bidding war rather than a forced sale. Anaheim is one example. Utah is mentioned too, with a potential package built around Logan Cooley, Dylan Guenther, and Tij Iginla.

That is real pressure on the market.

Of course, Matthews still controls everything with his no-movement clause. No one should forget that. He gets the final say on any destination, which means this is not simply Chayka deciding where to send him if things ever go that far.

But the bigger point remains.

Toronto is not trapped anymore.

If this stays quiet, fine.

If it gets louder, that may actually help the Leafs.

Because once a franchise lands the No. 1 pick and no longer has to act desperate, every Matthews rumor starts sounding less like a crisis and more like leverage.