Stan Bowman is getting a rare public defender this morning, and the Oilers front office will take every kind word it can get.
A post today made the case that flipping Andrew Mangiapane, a first-round pick, and a second-round pick for Connor Murphy, Jason Dickinson, and Colton Dach was "pretty solid work."
Fair enough. On paper, Bowman did move pieces.
Murphy gave the Oilers 80 regular-season games and posted 17 points. He went plus-3 over six playoff appearances.
Dickinson added penalty-kill depth at age 30. He chipped in 17 points across 64 games, including a shorthanded goal, and went plus-2 in four playoff contests.
Dach is the wild card. At 23, he's the only piece in this deal with actual upside left. He played 61 games, scored 13 points, and went minus-15.
Bowman gave up a first-rounder and the Oilers still lost to Anaheim in six
Here's the problem nobody wants to say out loud: the Oilers finished 41-30-11 and ranked 14th overall, then got bounced by Anaheim in the first round.
That's not Murphy's fault, and it's not Dickinson's fault either.
But giving up a first-round pick to add a 33-year-old blueliner at $4.4 million who produces 17 points is a hard case to make when the season ends in late April.
Mangiapane was never a superstar. He was younger, cheaper, and versatile enough to slot into the top six or bottom six.
Trading him plus two picks for three players who collectively carry $9.475 million in cap space and deliver depth-line production is the kind of move that sounds reasonable at the deadline.
Context doesn't cooperate with that framing. Context is a first-round loss to a team that wasn't supposed to beat you.
Bowman has made legitimate moves since arriving in Edmonton in July 2024, and nobody's pretending otherwise.
But this one deserves harder questions than what's circulating on X right now.
Connor McDavid put up 138 points in 82 regular-season games. Leon Draisaitl added 97 points in 65.
The two best players alive were wearing Oilers jerseys, and Edmonton still went home in six. That's the real indictment.
The supporting cast questions aren't going away this summer. They're the entire conversation.
Whether Colton Dach eventually turns into something real is the only sliver of optimism Bowman has left to sell on this particular deal.
-
Was Stan Bowman right to trade Andrew Mangiapane and two picks for Connor Murphy, Jason Dickinson, and Colton Dach?
Also read on Markerzone.com:
Two American-born players demand a trade from their longtime original team: What it means for Cole Caufield
