Edmonton Oilers defenceman Darnell Nurse is drawing trade interest this summer, and the Kings may already be the clearest fit.
NHL insider Jim Matheson floated the scenario Saturday, pointing to Los Angeles as the most straightforward landing spot for the 31-year-old blue-liner.
Matheson's logic isn't complicated. He cited history: teams rarely get top-shelf returns for defencemen north of 30 on big contracts.
His reference point was the Jacob Trouba deal, where the Rangers sent him to Anaheim for an $8M cap hit and got back what most would call a soft return.
That precedent matters here because Nurse carries a $9,250,000 cap hit.
That is not a number any acquiring team absorbs without squinting hard at the asset column.
Matheson suggested the simplest resolution for Los Angeles would be sending left defenceman Joel Edmundson back to Edmonton, a player carrying $3,850,000 against the cap with two years remaining.
Nurse's offensive numbers won't sell the return
Here is the uncomfortable part for the Oilers front office, led by GM Stan Bowman: the on-ice case for getting a premium in return is thin.
Nurse finished the regular season with 7 goals and 17 assists for 24 points in 82 games, going -12.
Over his last 10 games of the regular season, he had 1 assist. In the final 5, he was held scoreless.
Then came the playoffs. Six games against Anaheim, zero points. The Oilers lost the series in six and were done.
That's the sales pitch Bowman is walking into trade discussions with. Good luck.
Nurse is a physical presence and a veteran locker room voice, but Ken Holland's Kings finished with 90 points and a -22 goal differential. They are not in a position to overpay for a 31-year-old defenceman on a near-$10M ticket.
D.J. Smith, who took over as Kings head coach this past March, still has big questions to answer about what his blue line actually looks like long-term.
Edmundson as a return piece is less a blockbuster and more a cap-sheet puzzle piece. You ship out a big number, you absorb a manageable one, and you move on.
Whether Bowman can convince himself that is enough is a different question entirely.
The Trouba comparable Matheson raised is probably the most honest frame available here. You want a star return for a 30-something defenceman on a max deal? History says you are not getting it.
And the Oilers are at a crossroads. They built around McDavid and Draisaitl, got bounced in the first round, and now face an offseason where the cap math forces decisions the fan base is not going to love.
Nurse going out at a discount stings. Keeping him at $9.25M while retooling stings differently.
-
Should the Oilers accept a swap-style deal for Darnell Nurse, or hold out for a proper asset return?
Also read on Markerzone.com:
A trade has just been announced involving Sidney Crosby's Penguins
