Morgan Rielly and Darnell Nurse are back in Toronto's blue-line mess after the latest Nurse's trade idea popped online.
The proposal sounds simple on the surface: swap Rielly for Nurse with salary held back. The problem is that it fixes almost nothing for either team.
Start with Toronto. Rielly still feels more likely than ever to be explored in trade talks, but the Leafs are not looking to exchange one debated fit for another. That would be spinning the tires, not changing the room.
Rielly played 78 games last season and finished with 11 goals, 25 assists, and a -18 rating. Those numbers fed the criticism, but they also still show a puck-moving defenseman who drives offense better than Nurse does.
Nurse played all 82 games and put up 7 goals, 17 assists, and a -12 rating. He still eats minutes, still brings reach and physical push, but he does not solve Toronto's need for cleaner puck movement from the back end.
That is why the Leafs should say no first. If John Chayka moves Rielly, the goal should be reshaping the blue line, not importing another long-term debate piece with a different label.
-
A shocking Morgan Rielly trade proposal just surfaced and Leafs fans are divided
The Oilers have been ready and willing to move Nurse, and Stan Bowman was expected to speak with him about his wishes. That says plenty about Edmonton's direction.
But Rielly is not some automatic answer for Edmonton either. The Oilers' issue is not only puck movement. It is defending hard ice under pressure, especially once games tighten up in spring.
Rielly can help a power play and help exits. He does not naturally answer the same box-out and matchup questions Nurse has been asked to carry for years. That makes the swap feel cleaner on CapFriendly-style graphics than on an actual bench.
The contract piece also muddies everything. Nurse carries a $9.25 million cap hit, while Rielly sits at $7.5 million. Even with salary retention, both clubs are still locking into term on players their own markets already want to move.
And there is the player-control angle. Nurse's contract protection gives him major say in where he goes, which means Edmonton cannot just draw up a Leafs trade on a whiteboard and send it through.
This is why the fantasy trade misses. Toronto needs a truer stylistic pivot. Edmonton needs a cleaner roster answer around Connor McDavid's window.
Morgan Rielly for Darnell Nurse with money held back is the kind of deal fans talk themselves into because both names are under pressure. That does not make it a smart hockey trade.
Would a Morgan Rielly for Darnell Nurse swap help either team?
Also read on Markerzone.com:
Toronto Maple Leafs just received the Auston Matthews update it feared most
