SEARCH


Huge bad news for the Canadiens is suddenly sparking major controversy

PUBLICATION
Vincent Carbonneau
June 2, 2026  (8:52)
SHARE THIS STORY

May 29, 2026; Raleigh, North Carolina, USA; Montreal Canadiens head coach Martin St. Louis reacts as he walks on the ice after losing to the Carolina Hurricanes in game five of the Eastern Conference Final of the 2026 Stanley Cup Playoffs at Lenovo Center.
Photo credit: James Guillory-Imagn Images

Brendan Gallagher and Martin St-Louis now look tied to one of the coldest Canadiens decisions of the spring.

That is why this keeps coming back.

The complaint from fans is not only that Gallagher barely played in the Carolina series. It is that once it became obvious he was likely on his way out, Montreal still did not carve out even a small role for him.

That part is hard for people to shake.

Nobody is arguing Gallagher should have suddenly jumped back into a top-six role and played 18 minutes a night. That was never the point.

The point was simpler.

When the series was slipping, when the lineup needed a jolt, and when the emotional side of the room clearly mattered, the Canadiens still would not give him limited minutes.

That tells you plenty.

It tells you the organization may already have decided what Gallagher was to them by that stage.

I'm pretty upset with how the Gally situation unfolded in the playoffs, especially considering how clear it was that he was gonna be on his way out.

They had ample opportunities to play him limited minutes in the Carolina series when the series was dead and they never did it.

The Canadiens treated Gallagher like the ending had already been written

That is why the reaction has gotten so strong.

Gallagher spent years dragging this team into fights, planting himself at the crease, and doing the ugly work that made him one of the most recognizable players in the organization.

Then the playoffs arrive, the season starts dying, and he becomes almost invisible in the plan.

That is a rough way for this to end.

And honestly, it also sends a message beyond one veteran winger.

It tells the room that sentiment means nothing once a player is seen as outside the next version of the team. Coaches make hard calls all the time, but this one felt especially blunt because the Canadiens had opportunities to use him in a smaller, controlled role and still passed.

That is what makes people upset.

Not that Gallagher was no longer a core piece on the ice.

That was already clear.

It is that Montreal never seemed interested in letting him have any part in the finish, even when the series looked done and the risk was low.

Maybe St-Louis believed the pace was not there.

Maybe the staff believed the current group gave them a better chance.

Maybe Gallagher's fit was simply gone.

All of that can be true.

It still looked harsh.

Because once a player like Gallagher gets pushed this far to the edge, everyone sees the same thing. The relationship is not only cooling. It is closing.

And if that is what the playoffs revealed, then the summer conversation is no longer complicated.

Brendan Gallagher's exit does not only feel possible now.

It feels unavoidable.

POLL
1 HOUR AGO   |   164 ANSWERS
Huge bad news for the Canadiens is suddenly sparking major controversy

Did the Canadiens handle Brendan Gallagher's playoff situation the wrong way ?