SEARCH


The Leafs' coaching search may be nearing its conclusion after major new development

PUBLICATION
Vincent Carbonneau
May 31, 2026  (1:50 PM)
SHARE THIS STORY

Jan 18, 2025; Montreal, Quebec, CAN; View of a Toronto Maple Leafs logo on a jersey worn by a member of the team during the second period at Bell Centre.
Photo credit: David Kirouac-Imagn Images

David Carle and Craig Berube now sit at the center of Toronto's biggest coaching turn of the summer.

This one feels different.

For weeks, the Maple Leafs coaching search has sounded wide open, with names moving in and out, interviews stacking up, and John Chayka keeping the process loose.

Now the tone has changed.

The latest report says Toronto is closing in on naming Carle as its next head coach, and that immediately turns a long search into a real finish line.

That matters because Carle was never just another interview.

He was the swing.

He was the candidate who represented something fresher, sharper, and less tied to the usual NHL recycling loop that teams fall back on when pressure gets high.

" The Toronto Maple Leafs are reportedly closing in on naming David Carle as their next head coach. "

" According to The Toronto Star's Jonah Sigel, the Leafs will eventually name Carle as head coach.

It's Sat night , I'm in a good mood. 3 things I believe or I've been told. These are NOT rumors:
1. Chris MacFarland will end up in Nashville - big promotion & bigger raise
2. Morgan Riley will agree to get dealt to San Jose
3. The Leafs will name David Carle head coach "

The Leafs' next head coach may have just been revealed

That is why this would be such a statement hire.

Carle has built a strong reputation as a modern coach, someone players respond to and someone seen as more than just a safe development name.

If the Leafs are really moving toward him, then Chayka is telling everyone exactly what kind of reset he wants.

Not a louder version of the old model.

A different one.

That would also explain why some familiar NHL names never seemed to fully grab this search. Toronto talked to experienced options. It checked different backgrounds. But Carle always felt like the coach who could change the direction of the room, not just manage it.

And that is what the Leafs need.

This job is not only about systems, line changes, and special teams. It is about handling the market, commanding a star-heavy roster, and bringing a cleaner identity to a franchise that keeps getting stuck in the same emotional loop.

That is a huge ask for any coach.

It is an even bigger bet on someone who has been selective about when to make the jump.

That is why this report hits.

If Toronto is getting close, it means Carle is not only listening anymore. It means he may be ready to take on the biggest spotlight in hockey and make this his NHL entry point.

That is a massive development.

It also means the Leafs may finally be done flirting with possibilities and ready to land on one real answer.

If this closes, Toronto is not hiring the safest name on the board.

It is hiring the one with the most intrigue, the most upside, and maybe the most pressure attached to him from Day 1.