SEARCH


Major Habs player rumour just got confirmed and it's far worse than fans imagined

PUBLICATION
Jonathan Ouimet
May 31, 2026  (1:41)
SHARE THIS STORY

May 29, 2026; Raleigh, North Carolina, USA; Carolina Hurricanes defenseman Shayne Gostisbehere (4) scores a power play goal against Montreal Canadiens goaltender Jakub Dobes (75) in game five of the Eastern Conference Final of the 2026 Stanley Cup Playoffs during the second period at Lenovo Center.
Photo credit: James Guillory-Imagn Images

The Montreal Canadiens injury list keeps getting longer, and Kaiden Guhle is the latest name now confirmed on it.

Karine Hains of The Hockey News reported that the young defender was clearly playing through a significant issue from Game 4 of the Eastern Conference Final onward.

His body language during the critical Game 5 told the story. The face. The movement. The hesitation on routine plays. The eye test said one thing, even if no one inside the organization confirmed it publicly until now.

Guhle is now the fifth Canadiens core player named in connection with serious injury concerns this week. The list already included captain Nick Suzuki, Juraj Slafkovsky, Noah Dobson, and Lane Hutson per earlier reporting.

The 24-year-old defender finished his regular season with only 39 games played on a $5.55 million cap hit. Injuries have followed him since he entered the league.

He still suited up for all 16 of Montreal's playoff games. 8 assists. A plus-4 rating. The production held up. The eye test cracked at the end.

Why the Martin St-Louis decision is now in the spotlight

Several analysts are asking the obvious question. Should Martin St-Louis have pulled Guhle from the lineup once it was clear he wasn't physically able to compete at his usual level?

Knee injuries can compound fast. One bad pivot in a playoff series can become months of recovery in the off-season. The risk-reward equation gets ugly when the stakes outweigh the medical caution.

Arber Xhekaj sat for three playoff games during the same series. The 25-year-old has been a steady physical presence with 13 playoff games of his own, including a goal and a plus-5 rating in limited minutes.

Some fans believe Xhekaj would have offered more in a Game 5 where physical edge mattered. Others point out that pulling a top-four defender on the brink of elimination would have been an even riskier call.

Honestly, most NHL coaches in St-Louis' shoes would have made the same decision. Veterans want to play. Young players want to play more. Saying no in an elimination scenario is one of the hardest jobs a head coach has.

The bigger issue is the pattern. Five core players reportedly carrying significant injuries through a deep playoff run. That's not luck. That's the kind of accumulation a coaching staff has to plan around earlier in the season.

GM Kent Hughes will release the full medical update over the next few days. The Habs always wait until the off-season locker cleanout to share specifics. The community is bracing for what the report actually contains.

The off-season conversations now shift. Surgery decisions. Rehabilitation timelines. Training camp readiness. Roster planning around the recovery windows for multiple stars at once.

Guhle has fought through pain his entire NHL career. The courage isn't in question. The question is whether that courage should have had limits in a specific stretch of games that were always going to be uphill.

Martin St-Louis has a few weeks now to reflect on the decision. The organization has years to manage what comes next for Guhle's body.

The Habs spring ended in Carolina. The medical bill is still being totaled in Montreal.

POLL
1 HOUR AGO   |   31 ANSWERS
Major Habs player rumour just got confirmed and it's far worse than fans imagined

Should Martin St-Louis have sat Kaiden Guhle in Game 5 to protect his knee ?