SEARCH


Auston Matthews makes his decision on his Maple Leafs future after first meeting with John Chayka

PUBLICATION
Skyler Walker
May 25, 2026  (8:46)
SHARE THIS STORY

Apr 3, 2024; Toronto, Ontario, CAN; Toronto Maple Leafs forward Auston Matthews (34) gets congratulated after scoring against the Tampa Bay Lightning during the first period at Scotiabank Arena.
Photo credit: John E. Sokolowski-Imagn Images

Auston Matthews and former head coach Craig Berube won't be the last names tied to this Maple Leafs reset.

Toronto's ugly finish in 2025-26 cracked the door open to real doubt around Matthews, and he did little to shut it during his end-of-season media session.

«I mean, I can't predict the future,» Matthews said at the time, and that line poured fuel on a market already bracing for another summer of noise.

Trade chatter took off from there, especially with the Maple Leafs turning the page in the front office and putting John Chayka in charge of the next phase.

That's why Monday's update mattered.

Elliotte Friedman reported that Matthews, Chayka, and senior adviser Mats Sundin finally had their first long Zoom conversation.

And this confirmed everything.

It wasn't a formality. It was the first real chance for Toronto's new power structure to lay out the plan directly to its captain.

Toronto gets the answer it needed

«I understand at some point last week there was a lengthy zoom call,» Friedman said on the 32 Thoughts podcast. «It was sort of their first in depth conversation.»

Friedman added that Chayka and Sundin walked Matthews through their vision, how they want to build, and what the next version of the Maple Leafs is supposed to look like.

«I think it was the first time they could really have a conversation about what they are thinking, what their plan is, what their vision is, and how they are going to do it,» Friedman said.

The biggest takeaway wasn't just that the meeting happened. It was the tone coming out of it. By Friedman's read, Matthews liked what he heard, and nothing in that conversation pushed this toward a split.

«There's still a lot that has to happen here but I heard it was a positive meeting,» Friedman said. «I checked with as many people as I could and I was told that, right now, things are in a good place.»

That matters in a city where every offseason turn gets magnified. Toronto didn't need a grand speech from Matthews.

It needed a sign that the relationship still had traction.

Friedman followed with the clearest line of all:

«I was told there was nothing that raised any alarms, or any concerns, and right now things are in a good place between Matthews and the organization.»

He stopped short of a formal guarantee, but the message was plain enough. «I think the best way to put it is that he has indicated that he wants to win in Toronto,» Friedman said.

For the Maple Leafs, that's the first real win of the summer.

POLL
1 HOUR AGO   |   173 ANSWERS
Auston Matthews makes his decision on his Maple Leafs future after first meeting with John Chayka

Did Auston Matthews just end the trade talk for good ?