SEARCH


The conversation around Auston Matthews just changed dramatically after Friedman's latest comments

PUBLICATION
Vincent Carbonneau
May 20, 2026  (5:09 PM)
SHARE THIS STORY

Mar 11, 2023; Toronto, Ontario, CAN; Toronto Maple Leafs center Auston Matthews (34) battles with Edmonton Oilers center Connor McDavid (97) during the first period at Scotiabank Arena.
Photo credit: Nick Turchiaro-Imagn Images

Auston Matthews and former head coach Craig Berube still frame Toronto's reset, even with the Leafs now searching for a new voice.

That is why Elliotte Friedman's latest read matters so much.

For all the trade noise around Matthews, Friedman said he still believes the Leafs captain wants to win in Toronto. More than that, he said he would be surprised if Matthews is not in Toronto next season.

That should cool a lot of wild summer talk right away.

But it does not let the organization off the hook.

Because Friedman added the part that really matters now. Matthews does not only want to hear what the Leafs plan to do. He wants to know how they are going to do it, and what the timeline looks like.

That is a very different conversation than simple loyalty.

It puts the pressure exactly where it belongs, on John Chayka and Mats Sundin. The new leadership group does not need to convince Matthews to care. He already does.

Elliotte Friedman: I think Auston Matthews wants to win in Toronto, I do, I don't think that's ever changed; at the base, he wants to be in Toronto, and I would be surprised if he wasn't in Toronto next year - NHL Now (5/18)

We also have this about another superstar that could be on the move :

Elliotte Friedman's latest Auston Matthews report is shaking Leafs fans

This is where the whole thing sharpens. Matthews has signed deals that could tie him to Toronto for 12 years, and Friedman made the point that contracts like that speak louder than empty reassurance.

So this is not a star trying to bolt at the first sign of trouble.

It is a star looking at the people above him and asking whether there is a real path here.

That makes total sense after the year Toronto just had. The Leafs missed the playoffs, fired Brad Treliving on March 30, then moved on from Berube after 2 seasons behind the bench.

Now Chayka owns the biggest summer in the market.

Matthews is signed through 2028 at a 13.25 million cap hit. That gives Toronto structure, but it also gives the front office a clear responsibility to build something worthy of that window.

And Matthews still has to feel like the plan matches the urgency.

His season gave the Leafs another reminder that nothing can be taken for granted. He played 60 games and finished with 27 goals and 26 assists, a drop from the standard people expect from him.

That makes the supporting cast, the coaching hire, and the roster shape even more important.

So yes, this update is good news for Toronto. Matthews wants to be there.

But it is also a warning.

The captain is not asking for blind faith. He is asking for a roadmap. If Chayka and Sundin can show him one, the noise around Matthews dies quickly.

If they cannot, it only gets louder.