SEARCH


Father of Steve Montador files second lawsuit in son's death

PUBLICATION
TJ Tucker
October 29, 2021  (12:54)
SHARE THIS STORY

Paul Montador's six-year legal battle against the NHL over the death of his son Steve Montador has taken another turn after he filed a second lawsuit against the NHL recently.

It's been 10 months since a judge dismissed the first lawsuit filed in Montador's death. The ruling at that time said that some claims made by Paul were preempted by the NHL's collective labour agreement with the NHLPA, which directs players with medical-related grievances to pursue private arbitration. However, the judge allowed Paul to proceed in state court to pursue negligence claims against the NHL that allege the league has unreasonably promoted a culture of violence, and led Steve to believe that the repeated brain trauma he suffered was not dangerous.

In his new claim, Paul says his son Steve suffered "thousands of sub-concussive brain traumas and multiple concussions, many of which were undiagnosed and/or undocumented."

"The NHL, armed with vastly superior managerial, medical, legal, and other resources to gather, analyze, and understand sub-concussion, concussion and head injury data, failed to keep Steven Montador reasonably safe during his career and misled him on the permanent ramifications of brain trauma," says the lawsuit.

Steve Montador played for 10 seasons in the NHL with six different teams, getting involved in some documented 69 fights throughout his career. He had a well-documented history of concussions, depression, memory problems and erratic behaviour.

"In 2007, during Steven Montador's sixth year in the league, the NHL was queried on the juxtaposition of 'knocked out' boxers sitting out from further fights for 60-90 days, while the NHL Enforcers/Fighters, even when knocked out, can come back into the game almost immediately. The NHL thought this was a good question, but did nothing to act on the provocative reality," said the new lawsuit.

The NHL has yet to file a response to the lawsuit. However, in the previous one, it stated that Steve's injuries were "caused, in whole or in part, by [Montador's] own lack of due care and fault, and/or by pre-existing conditions; and/or the lack of due care of others for whom the NHL has no responsibility or control." Following his death, Montador was diagnosed with CTE from repeated concussions.

Source: TSN.ca

TRENDING NOW
2025-2026
NHL STANDINGS
GPWLOLPTS
Sabres8250239109
Lightning8250266106
Canadiens82482410106
Bruins82452710100
Senators8244271199
Red Wings8241311092
Panthers824038484
Maple Leafs8232361478
GPWLOLPTS
Hurricanes8253227113
Penguins8241251698
Flyers8243271298
Capitals824330995
Blue Jackets8240301292
Islanders824334591
Devils824237387
Rangers823439977
GPWLOLPTS
Avalanche82551611121
Stars82502012112
Wild82462412104
Mammoth824333692
Blues8237331286
Predators8238341086
Jets8235351282
Blackhawks8229391472
GPWLOLPTS
Golden Knights8239261795
Oilers8241301193
Ducks824333692
Kings8235272090
Sharks823935886
Kraken8234371179
Flames823439977
Canucks822549858
COMPLETE STANDINGS